Replacing Puppet with Customer Data Platforms: An Honest Review

Authentication turned out to be the most politically charged decision in the entire project. Every team had opinions about OAuth providers, session management strategies, and token lifetimes. We eventually settled on a pragmatic middle ground that nobody loved but everyone could live with.

Scaling Challenges

Feature flags transformed our release process more than any CI/CD improvement. Decoupling deployment from release meant we could merge code daily, test in production with internal users, and gradually roll out to customers — all while maintaining the ability to instantly revert without a code deployment.

Post-mortems without action items are just storytelling. We implemented a strict follow-up process: every post-mortem produces at most three concrete action items, each assigned to a specific person with a deadline. Items that don’t get done within two sprints get escalated or explicitly deprioritized.

We started this project with a clear hypothesis: the existing approach was costing us more in maintenance time than the migration would cost upfront. Three months later, the data confirmed we were right — but the journey was far bumpier than expected.

We adopted a writing culture where every significant technical decision gets documented in a lightweight RFC. These aren’t formal or bureaucratic — just a shared Google Doc with problem statement, proposed approach, alternatives considered, and decision rationale. Six months in, the archive has become our most valuable knowledge base.

Our initial benchmark numbers looked promising in staging but fell apart under production traffic patterns. The difference? Staging used uniform request distributions while real users exhibit bursty, correlated behavior that exposes different bottlenecks entirely.

Infrastructure Decisions

We stopped doing quarterly planning and switched to six-week cycles with two-week cooldowns. The cooldowns are for tech debt, experiments, and developer-chosen projects. Team satisfaction scores jumped 30% and, counterintuitively, feature delivery actually accelerated.

Thank you to everyone who reviewed early drafts of this post and pushed back on the parts that were too vague or too self-congratulatory. The final version is much better for their honesty.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *